Award-Winning Podcast? That Will Be $199, Please.
It’s 6:17 a.m. on Monday, November 16, 2026. Nine minutes ago, at 6:08 a.m., I received an email. It was the first email I saw this morning, and it may have provided one of the most fascinating insights into the modern podcasting industry that I have encountered in a while.
The subject line?
“20 trophies. Which one has your name on it? 🏆”
The email was promoting the second annual Podcast Tonight Awards. Twenty categories. Twenty trophies. An opportunity to have your podcast recognized as one of the best.
There was just one little detail.
It would cost me $199.
Well, technically, that’s the early entry price. If I wait until December 1, it will cost me $299. But if I really want to increase my chances of becoming an award-winning podcaster, I can take advantage of something called the Triple Threat Bundle. For just $499, I can enter three categories. If I wait until December 1, that same bundle will cost me $749.
You can see the awards website for yourself:
https://podcasttonightawards.com/
Now, I have been podcasting for years. I have produced thousands of episodes. Theology Central has accumulated over a million lifetime streams across its various platforms. I have spent countless hours behind a microphone, often in the middle of the night, working through biblical texts, examining theological arguments, reviewing sermons, challenging interpretations, and sometimes discovering that the question I started with has led to ten more questions I never anticipated.
But apparently, I have been missing something.
I haven’t been spending money trying to win trophies.
And before anyone misunderstands what I am about to say, I am not claiming that the Podcast Tonight Awards are fraudulent. I am not claiming that paying an entry fee guarantees a victory, that the judges are dishonest, or that the winners are predetermined. Many legitimate awards competitions charge entry fees. There may be excellent podcasts that enter this competition and genuinely deserve recognition.
But I want to examine what this email actually says, because I think it reveals something about the podcasting industry that listeners should understand.
The email encourages podcasters to enter multiple categories. It even offers a helpful little pro tip:
“Most podcasters enter three categories: their genre, one Headline Award and one Craft Award. That’s three chances to win and three voting pages to share with your audience.”
Three chances to win.
For $499.
Think about that for a moment. A podcast with a larger marketing budget can purchase entry into multiple categories, increasing its opportunities to walk away with an award. A podcast with no marketing budget, or one that simply refuses to participate, will never be considered.
So when someone announces that they have won an award for being the best podcast in a particular category, what exactly does that mean?
Were they the best podcast in that category? Or were they judged the best among the podcasts that paid to enter that category?
Those are two very different claims.
But the distinction will almost certainly disappear when the winner updates their podcast description, website, social media accounts, and promotional material. The words that will remain are the words everyone wants:
Award-winning podcast.
And those words carry weight. They create an impression. They suggest that someone has examined the vast world of podcasting, discovered this particular podcast, evaluated its content, and concluded that it stands above the others.
But that may not be what happened at all.
Then I came across something in the email that made me stop.
Every entrant receives official nominee graphics for all their social media channels. These materials are promised within 72 hours of entering.
Every entrant.
Let that sink in.
If I understand the email correctly, I could pay $199 this morning, enter Theology Central into a category, and potentially have official nominee graphics by Thursday.
I could put them on TheologyCentral.net. I could put them on TheologyCentral.org. I could announce it to the listeners. I could create a social media post celebrating the exciting news that Theology Central has been nominated for a podcast award.
And what would have happened between Monday morning and Thursday?
I would have spent $199.
No independent organization would necessarily have discovered Theology Central. No panel of judges would necessarily have listened to thousands of hours of teaching and determined that this podcast deserved special recognition. No one would necessarily have evaluated my handling of Scripture, my theological arguments, or the quality of the content.
I would have entered a competition.
But now I would have graphics that say I am an official nominee.
Do you see the problem?
There is a significant difference between being nominated because someone has recognized the quality of your work and receiving nominee status as part of a package you purchased.
The graphics may look the same. The announcement may sound the same. The impression created in the minds of potential listeners may be the same.
The reality behind it may be very different.
And this email gets even more interesting.
One of the reasons I am encouraged to enter today is that entering earlier gives me more time to collect votes. The earlier I enter, the sooner my personal voting page goes live, and the longer I have to rally my listeners.
So imagine two podcasts competing in the same category. One enters today, November 16. The other enters on December 24, just before entries close.
One has weeks to campaign, solicit votes, send emails, post on social media, and play its custom promotional jingle. The other has dramatically less time.
If public voting influences the outcome, what exactly are we measuring?
The quality of the podcasts? The excellence of the content? The creativity of the hosts? Or are we measuring the ability of podcasters to mobilize their audiences, promote themselves, and collect votes over unequal periods of time?
And then there is the sentence that may reveal more than anything else in the entire email:
“More time means more votes, and more votes means more email subscribers.”
There it is.
This isn’t simply about recognizing excellence in podcasting. It is also about audience acquisition, email marketing, promotional campaigns, and building a brand.
Every entrant receives a personal voting page. Every entrant receives a custom podcast jingle to encourage listeners to vote. Every entrant receives official nominee graphics. Every entrant receives the email addresses of voters who opt in.
The podcast awards are being sold, at least in significant part, as a marketing opportunity.
The organization receives entry fees. Podcasters promote the competition to their listeners. Listeners visit the voting pages. Podcasters potentially gain email subscribers. The competition gains exposure. Eventually, awards are handed out, and the winners gain another promotional tool.
It is a fascinating business model.
But somewhere in the middle of all of this, I find myself asking a very simple question.
What happened to the actual podcast?
What happened to the content? What happened to the ideas? What happened to the hours spent researching, studying, preparing, thinking, questioning, and communicating?
What happened to the podcast that exists because someone has something to say, not because someone has a brand to build?
I have been thinking a lot recently about the modern podcasting industry. I have looked at podcast networks, curated collections, promotional strategies, and the increasingly manufactured nature of so much podcast content. Everything begins to look the same, sound the same, and feel the same. The artwork. The descriptions. The production. The presentation. The carefully crafted personal brands.
And now I am looking at an email telling me that for $199, I can enter the world of podcast awards, receive official nominee graphics, get a custom jingle, and begin collecting votes and email subscribers.
Perhaps this helps explain why the podcasting world sometimes feels less like a world of independent voices and more like a world of competing marketing campaigns.
And I think there is an especially important application for Christian podcasting.
How many times have you encountered a Christian podcast described as an award-winning podcast? How many times have you seen that language used to establish credibility, authority, or the impression that this particular ministry is something exceptional?
Have you ever stopped to ask what the award actually means?
Who gave it? Who was eligible? Did the podcast pay to enter? How many podcasts competed? Who judged the content? What were the criteria? Was the theology evaluated? Was the handling of Scripture evaluated? Did the judges even possess the theological or biblical knowledge necessary to evaluate those things?
Or was it a competition in which audience size, production quality, promotional activity, and public voting played a significant role?
Because I can assure you of something.
A podcast can win an award and still mishandle Scripture.
A podcast can win an award and still promote theological error.
A podcast can win an award and still offer shallow, superficial, recycled content.
A podcast can win an award and still fail to challenge anyone to think.
And a podcast can spend years producing thoughtful, challenging, substantive material without ever receiving a single trophy.
The absence of an award tells me very little about the quality of a podcast. And depending on the award, the presence of one may tell me very little as well.
I am not suggesting that there is anything inherently wrong with entering an awards competition. I am not suggesting that a podcaster should feel guilty for winning one. If you want to spend your money entering competitions, promoting your show, and asking your listeners to vote, that is your decision.
But I think we need to be more honest about what these awards represent.
There is a difference between being recognized for excellence and participating in a competition designed, in part, to help you market yourself. There is a difference between being independently nominated and receiving nominee graphics after paying an entry fee. There is a difference between producing something of value and acquiring the promotional materials that create the appearance of value.
And perhaps listeners need to become a little more skeptical of the language the podcasting industry uses.
Don’t tell me your podcast is award-winning and expect that to settle the question of whether I should listen to it.
Tell me what your podcast is about. Tell me what you are exploring. Tell me what questions you are asking. Tell me what you are doing that is worth my time.
Better yet, let me listen.
Let me hear the content. Let me evaluate the arguments. Let me examine the evidence. Let me determine whether what you are producing is worth returning to.
I don’t need a trophy to tell me what to think.
It is now early Monday morning, and somewhere in my inbox is an invitation to spend $199 on the possibility of becoming an award-winning podcaster.
For $499, I can apparently triple my opportunities.
But I think I will do what I have been doing for years.
I will turn on the microphone. I will open the Bible. I will listen to sermons. I will read theology. I will ask questions. I will challenge ideas. I will make mistakes, correct them, learn something new, and hopefully produce something that gives someone else a reason to think.
And when I finish, I will turn off the microphone.
No trophy.
No official nominee graphics.
No custom jingle asking everyone to vote for me.
Just another episode of Theology Central.
And then, hopefully, another one.
Because I didn’t start a podcast to win an award.
I started a podcast because I had something to say.